Breaking News
Local News

Closure Controversy

Businesses protest city’s blocking roadway

By Brad Johnson 4 min read
The Inter-Mountain photo by Anthony Gaynor A block of Davis Avenue in Elkins has been closed for much of the summer due to renovation work on the historic Tygart Hotel, which involves the use of a boom lift crane.
Watson

Watson

ELKINS -- A downtown business owner spoke before Elkins City Council to express her displeasure with the closure for much of the summer the block of Davis Avenue where her business is located.

Emily Watson, owner of the Clementine's Closet thrift store, during the meeting's public comment section told city officials she thought it was unfair to close that block of Davis Avenue for so long in order for renovation on the historic Tygart Hotel to proceed, without considering the other businesses on the block.

Businesses that she said have been affected by the block closure include Byrd's House of Donuts, the Mossy Merchant, Mycelium, Salon Swish, Trickett Hardware, Pawnbrokers, Pioneer Insurance and Ceramics With Class.

Watson told The Inter-Mountain earlier this week that she would be seeking financial reimbursement from the city.

"We are not here to request money from you tonight, as I have since learned such requests have to go through the Finance Committee," Watson said during Thursday's meeting. "I still find it imperative that we explain our disappointment with the lack of city support for our businesses.

"There's a lot of change happening downtown, good, positive change. There needs to be better communication and better plans to keep everyone informed."

The block has been closed repeatedly in recent months due to the use of a boom lift crane in the street as part of the hotel renovation work.

"At one point, and for over two weeks, there was a total of three cranes on Davis Avenue," Watson said. "Pedestrians and customers have to - and most won't - walk under the cranes and around random road blocks and equipment to get into our businesses ... All the cranes, roadblocks and equipment are simply bad for business. You see these on the road, you go the other way. And that's exactly what people are doing."

Watson said she and other businesses are in favor of the Tygart Hotel being renovated and reopened.

"We are all very excited about the hotel, and the traffic it has the potential to bring. But you are forgetting your already up-and-running tax-paying businesses on the same road," she said.

"Why should all of our businesses fail in order for one to succeed?"

Watson also read a letter from two other Davis Avenue business owners, Katie Driver and Emily Prentice, who own Mossy Merchant and Mycelium, respectively.

"Across multiple businesses, we have noted a significant decrease in sales coinciding with the extended road closure," the letter reads. "We believe that this problem is in part because of the road closure, in part because of the sidewalk closure, and in part because of the lack of clear communication and signage that our businesses are still open."

Watson also thanked Fourth Ward Councilman Andrew Carrol and Fifth Ward Councilman Cody Thompson for visiting the downtown business owners to hear their concerns.

No city officials responded to Watson's public comment statements, but the City of Elkins did post on social media Thursday that the large boom lift crane on Davis Avenue was being removed, "but will need to return in a few weeks."

The city's post also stated that the Davis Avenue Bridge would not be undergoing renovation this year, and so the city "will be in a position to provide a great deal of advance information before any closures occur."

Prior to Watson speaking in the public comment section, City Clerk Sutton Stokes said, "I was just asked to read a couple notes on the procedure. Just want to make sure you know council's very appreciative of the public's input, but has put some rules in place to make sure council stays on topic, has time to address the public business that we've been working on and that appears on our agenda tonight.

"During public comments, city residents have the right to speak for five minutes on topics that are on tonight's agenda," Stokes said. "Topics that are not on tonight's agenda require the unanimous consent of council to be heard. Also, the West Virginia Open Meetings Act prohibits council from discussing matters that are not on tonight's agenda. For further information about contacting your council members and about how council conducts business, you can always get in touch with me."

All council members present voted to allow Watson to speak during public comment, as her topic was not on the meeting's agenda. All council members were present Thursday except for Fifth Ward's Cody Thompson.

Starting at /week.