Randolph BOE votes down realignment plan
Plan would have closed Pickens School, Midland Elementary
Trending
ELKINS – The Randolph County Board of Education voted against Superintendent of Schools Dr. Derek Lambert's recommendation to move forward with a Comprehensive School Realignment plan during Thursday evening's regular meeting.
If approved, the plan would have allowed the county's school system to move forward with the planning and completion of closure impact statements, and the scheduling of closure hearings for Pickens School and Midland Elementary.
Two votes were taken, one regarding the Pickens part of the realignment plan, and the other centering on the Midland part of the plan.
Board member Randy Long recused himself from the Pickens vote, which deadlocked at 2-2. Peggy Young Ross and Ed Daniels voted against the proposal, while Rachel Burns and Denise Campbell voted yes. Long recused himself due to his wife being employed at Pickens School.
The BOE then voted 3-2 against the plan for Midland Elementary. Long, Young Ross, and Daniels voted against the plan, while Burns and Campbell voted yes.
The closure plan would have shuttered Pickens School, with those students merging into existing George Ward Elementary and Tygarts Valley Middle/High School.
The plan also would have closed Midland Elementary, with those students merging into existing Beverly Elementary School.
Before the Board voted on the recommendations, Lambert said he wanted to clear some things up.
“When we take the vote, that vote is to not close schools, it is simply to allow me and the staff here at the Central Office to move forward with collecting the data, making the documents that we have, and bringing all of that information to the public and to you all, and to schedule the hearings,” Lambert said. “So, neither of these two votes is a vote to close a school at this point.”
Lambert said he also wanted to clarify that the recommendation was his next step toward improving Randolph County’s school system, which has lost 750 students over a span of six years. The loss of 243 students this year alone is what led to Lambert’s Comprehensive School Realignment plan, he said.
“While no one wants to close a building or cut staff, I believe a vote tonight represents an inflection point for Randolph County Schools and for this Board of Education,” Lambert said. “The decision before you is whether we continue prioritizing resources for our schools, administrators, teachers, and students. Or we begin to shift those resources toward facilities at the expense of our educational programs and student safety. My priority as the superintendent will always be high-quality education opportunities for students, student safety, and supporting our school level administrators and teachers.”
Lambert told the BOE that a no-vote would necessitate approximately 37 additional staff reductions during the upcoming RIFF and transfer season.
“Nearly 90% (reductions) will have to come from either Elkins High School or Tygarts Valley Middle/High School, representing approximately 45% of the combined teaching staff at those two schools, ” Lambert said. “I cannot identify reductions of this magnitude without jeopardizing student safety, the quality of our secondary education, and the support our students deserve.”
Lambert added that a no-vote would leave the district with little, if any, viable options when it comes to balancing next year’s budget without depleting Randolph County Schools’ general fund balance. He said that would put the school system at “substantial risk for West Virginia Board of Education intervention.”
“A yes vote provides an opportunity to reduce those staffing cuts by at least half if not more, while preserving educational opportunities and allowing us to better support our students,” Lambert said during his comments. “It will allow our teachers, principals and county office staff to remain focused on improving student outcomes.”
Lambert said Randolph County educators and leaders were doing great thing,s and that he believes there will be improvement if everyone is willing to invest in the people doing the work and the students who depend on them.
“This is simply not a decision about buildings, it’s a decision about our priorities, our students, and the future of Randolph County Schools,” Lambert said. “Investing in improved academic outcomes will attract students back into our successful and thriving school system, I envision, if we build it.”
In October 2025, the BOE voted against closing Midland Elementary and Coalton Elementary.
The closing of the Pickens School was also originally to be voted on last year, but the hearing and vote were canceled by then-Superintendent Dr. Shawn Dilly, who said "new information related to funding" had arisen. That information was never shared with the public.
The West Virginia Board of Education originally placed Randolph County Schools in a State of Emergency for a six-month period in June 2025 because of its inability to balance the 2026 budget. The state BOE then voted to extend the State of Emergency status for another six months in January of this year.
In July, the state BOE voted unanimously to release Randolph County Schools from its State of Emergency status.
The next Randolph County Board of Education meeting will be Dec. 1 at 5:30 p.m.