Breaking News
Local News

Upshur, state BOEs sued over band competition

Lawsuit claims breach of contract before Buckhannon event

By Taylor McKinnie 8 min read

BUCKHANNON – The Upshur County Board of Education and the West Virginia Board of Education are being sued for alleged breach of contract over an incident involving the 2023 World Association of Marching Show Bands Championship, which was held in Buckhannon.

On Sept. 1, the World Association of Marching Show Bands (WAMSB) Buckhannon Host Committee, Inc. filed a lawsuit in Kanawha County Circuit Court, listing both the Upshur County Board of Education and the West Virginia Board of Education as defendants.

The lawsuit alleges that, after the state Board of Education took control of Upshur County schools, both entities breached an agreement with the host committee to supply buses, school facilities, food services and more for the World Association of Marching Show Bands Championship, which brought bands from around the world to Buckhannon in July 2023.

The WAMSB Buckhannon Host Committee is being represented by attorney Erika Klie Kolenich of Klie Law Offices in Buckhannon. The Upshur County Board of Education is being represented by attorneys Corey Lee Palumbo and Leigh Anne Wilson of Bowles Rice LLP, while the West Virginia Board of Education is being represented by attorney Anthony David Eates, II. The case is being heard by Eighth Judicial Circuit Court Judge Jennifer Bailey.

An amended complaint was filed on Oct. 20, adding additional information regarding the West Virginia State Board of Education’s takeover of the Upshur County school system in June 2023.

Both the original and amended complaints state that, in June 2020, WAMSB Buckhannon Host Committee president – and Buckhannon city recorder – Randy Sanders began preparing a proposal for the 2023 World Championships to take place in the City of Buckhannon. During this process, Sanders contacted the Upshur County Board of Education through then-Superintendent Dr. Sarah Stankus to inform them about the proposal and to request the Board assist in facilitating the event, if Buckhannon was selected as the host city.

The request included the use of Upshur County school gymnasiums and locker rooms for housing and showers for the participating bands, the use of the Buckhannon-Upshur High School football field and other available fields, and that the use of these facilities “be donated, free of charge,” in exchange for the Upshur County Board of Education being named a sponsoring entity of the event.

Stankus reportedly expressed “excitement and a desire to continue the conversation,” and provided a letter of support for the event from the Board upon Sander’s request for one. The complaint states the Board “promptly provided such a letter and offered its ‘full cooperation’ in hosting the event.” Similar letters of support were submitted by the City of Buckhannon, West Virginia Wesleyan College, the governor of West Virginia and two sitting U.S. senators, the lawsuit states. Buckhannon was then selected as the host city for the 2023 championship.

“Following up on Defendant’s (the Upshur County Board of Education’s) enthusiastic support of the project, the Plaintiff (WAMSB Buckhannon Host Committee) and Laura Meadows, Executive Director of the Upshur County Convention and Visitors Bureau, met with Jeffrey Perkins, Treasurer of the (Upshur County Board of Education), to discuss Plaintiff's needs and expectations from the (Board),” the original and amended complaints state. “During this meeting the Plaintiff renewed the request Mr. Sanders originally made in his individual capacity for use of gymnasiums and locker rooms for lodging and athletic fields for band practices and/or competitions. In this meeting, Plaintiff further requested the use of cafeterias and school-employed cooks to provide meals for competition participants and the use of school buses with drivers for transportation of participants.”

According to the complaint, an email from the Upshur County Board of Education dated Dec. 9, 2022 “offered to provide all services and use of facilities” requested by host committee. The Board also reportedly provided a detailed schedule of fees to be paid by the host committee. The host committee accepted this offer and “extensive and detailed emails” were exchanged between the two parties in the spring of 2023. The emails reportedly pertained to coordinating the schedule, exact number of busses, drivers and more.

The West Virginia Board of Education would later take control of the Upshur County Board of Education on June 14, 2023, after the State Board uncovered widespread financial mismanagement and misuse of federal pandemic relief funds from the COVID-19 pandemic. Four days after the takeover, the host committee reached out to the new interim superintendent regarding “the longstanding agreement” between the committee and the Board. The interim superintendent reportedly advised that he would discuss the agreement with representatives of the State Board and then give a response.

On June 21, 2023 – less than a month before the event – the host committee was advised that the Upshur County Board of Education and the West Virginia State Board of Education “intended to breach the agreement and or promises previously made,” and would not provide the “agreed-on services, transportation or facilities,” the complaint states. The World Association of Marching Show Bands Championship was still held in Buckhannon from July 17-24, 2023.

Two counts are listed in both the original and amended complaints, breach of contract and promissory estoppel, which could allow a promisee to recover damages.

Under the first count of breach of contract, the host committee alleges the Upshur County Board of Education “agreed to and was bound by certain terms and conditions” from the original contract. They also allege the West Virginia Board of Education became “jointly and severally liable for performance under the contract” when it took over the Upshur County Board of Education in June 2023.

“Both Defendants failed to abide by and/or follow the terms and conditions of the contract and the same constitutes a breach of contract,” the complaint states. “As a direct and proximate result of Defendants' breach of contract, Plaintiff has been forced to suffer damages and losses…”

The second count of promissory estoppel is noted as an “alternative pleading” and states, if the court does determine that no enforceable contract exists, the Host Committee will assert a claim for promissory estoppel. In this count, the Host Committee alleges the defendants “made clear and definite promises” which was established by “clear and convincing evidence through significant written correspondence.”

In regard to damages, the host committee alleges they suffered compensatory and consequential damages “including serious financial loss of paying for the services” the Upshur County Board of Education had agreed to contribute, “including but not limited to transportation costs, and attorney fees.” The host committee in its complaint “demands” judgment against both entities “in an amount in excess of the minimum jurisdictional limits of compensatory damages, consequential damages, plus attorney fees, interest and costs, and such further relief as a Court or jury may find just under and up to the limits of the State's liability insurance coverage.”

According to circuit court records, the Upshur County Board of Education and the West Virginia BOE have each made several motions asking the court to dismiss the lawsuit. In a motion filed Nov. 9, the Upshur County BOE argues the case should be dismissed as it fails to set forth any claim upon which relief can be granted. The Upshur Board also argues it has qualified immunity as it was a "state actor" working under the State Board of Education’s control, and that the alleged contract was against the West Virginia State Board of Education’s policy to begin with.

“Dr. Stankus had no statutory or other authority to enter into an agreement with Plaintiff (the host committee) that violated WVBE Policy 8200,” the Upshur BOE’s dismissal motion states. “Moreover, Dr. Stankus had no statutory or other authority to bind a future board with an oral contract. To the contrary, Dr. Stankus had a duty to execute all WVBE policies, including WVBE Policy 8200. Thus, the unauthorized act or ultra vires promises of Dr. Stankus could not have a binding effect on the Board…”

“…Thus, this Court should find that the Board was a ‘state actor’ entitled to qualified immunity pursuant to the (State Board) intervention on June 14, 2023, and entitled to void the Board's alleged contract with Plaintiff. In fact, termination of the alleged contract between Plaintiff and the Board was necessary to correct the mistake and the violations of (State Board) Policy 8200. As to the Board and/or the (State Board)’s discretionary decision to terminate the alleged agreement, the Board and the (State Board) are undoubtedly entitled to qualified immunity, which serves as a bar to all Plaintiff's claims. Thus, the Board is entitled to dismissal of all Plaintiff's claims based on qualified immunity.”

Starting at /week.