Kayley Marie Fenstermacher

Kayley was born on May 23, 2003, in Elkins, West Virginia, a daughter to Amanda Dawn Cobb, of Moatsville, and the late Kenny Fenstermacher.

Kayley leaves behind her brother, R.J. Fenstermacher of Fairmont West Virginia; maternal grandmother, Patrica Cobb of Moatsville; future stepmom, Juanita Haden; maternal aunts, Renee Evans and Shanna Mayle; maternal uncle, Roger Barcus; paternal uncles, Thomas Fenstermacher and wife, Fran, Buster Fenstermacher and wife, Adrian, David Fenstermacher and wife, Debbie; paternal aunts, Fay Lynn Sandridge and husband, Rick, Ellen Harris and husband, Rick; several, cousins; and friends three of which was just like family to Kayley, Gena Kelley, Beth Ann Howdyshell and Larry Frey.

Proceeding her in death was her father, Kenny Fenstermacher; and her sister, Keana Fenstermacher, who perished in the fire; paternal grandparents, Thomas B. Fenstermacher and Nancy Louise (Strawder) Fenstermacher; and maternal grandfather, Ronald Cobb.

Miss Fenstermacher was a Christian by faith and she attended the schools of Barbour County and was a graduate from Philip Barbour High School with the class of 2021.

Kayley was a sandwich artist at the Subway in Belington. She loved being outside, camping, and traveling. Kayley enjoyed playing video games, and loved to watch wrestling with her family and friends. She loved to spoil Beth Anne’s children most of all.

Family and friends may gather at the Auditorium on the campus of Battlers Knob 101 College Hill Rd., Philippi WV on Sunday, July 12, 2026, from 5 until 8 p.m. and again on Monday, July 13, 2026, from 9 a.m. until 11 a.m. the funeral hour, with Pastor Rick Williams officiating. Burial will follow in the Trinity Cemetery near Junior, where she will be laid to rest with her father and sister.

The Kittle Family Funeral Home 265 Beech Ave., Philippi is honored to be assisting the family with the arrangements.

Online condolences may be expressed to the family at www.kittlefamilyfh.com.