Breaking News
Columnists

Long shot or profound impact?

By Dr. David Turner 3 min read

Mary Boykin Chestnut, wife of South Carolina Senator James Chestnut, noted a conversation aboard a train near Fernandina, Georgia, after Abraham Lincoln won the presidency in November 1860. Her companion muttered, “Look out! Lincoln elected," and pointed to a man with a telegram. The news was electrifying; Chestnut committed to her diary: “The die is cast – sad forebodings are useless; the stake is like life or death.”

This sentiment should be noted after the Democratic rout of Republicans in the 2026 midterms. Although it involved Congress and not a presidential election, the impact is profound. Given the radicalism of Trumpism, with its fantasies of altering the basic foundations of the U.S. government, it introduces disturbing questions. For the MAGA remnant, the stakes are as stern and unnerving as they were in the South in 1860. Given the Jan. 6, 2021 coup attempt, it raises eyebrows about Jan. 3, 2027, and the present Congress’s vote to accept the election results.

Indeed, there has been a collective sigh of relief that Trump has not challenged the results. But note that in the South, there was no rush in November 1860; after Lincoln’s election, talk of “Cooperationists” in the South preventing any rash action abounded. But their hopes proved unfounded. Trump has recently ratcheted up the rhetoric and appointed Stephen Miller as his Chief of Staff. One minute he is all peace; the next, it is “fight them on the beaches.”

Given his track record on surprises, from January 6, 2021, to his “liberation day” on tariffs, to the attack on Iran, his credibility is not worth much. The reason is clear: Trump populism is based on the fears of a segment of the population. In Lincoln’s day, the partisanship paralleled the intensity of the present day. Although it was limited to the South in 1860, the existential struggle was omnipresent; as Chestnut noted from the train, the first reactions reflected what was to come. “Now did you ever,” one of Chestnut’s fellow passengers blurted, “Now that the black Republicans have the power I suppose they will Brown us all. No doubt of it.” Brown, of course, referred to John Brown, who tried to seize the federal arsenal at Harper’s Ferry in October 1859.

With the South in 2026 looking a little more blue, a desperation has spread over MAGA. They may have doubts about Trump, but they’ll stick by him as loyal guardsmen. No doubt Stephen Bannon would reluctantly become Trump’s George Pickett in the next few weeks. Desperation is a poor substitute for judgment. The Miller pick was an ill-considered declaration of hostility toward the election. The swearing-in for the new Congress may be more interesting than usual.

Again, it may be a long shot, but history does not favor such a result. During the midterm campaign, Trump went back and forth. One minute he appeared more an observer than a participant. At times he seemed lucid one minute, only to fulminate about “Communists” and “vegans”. This last year, he has been the loosest of cannons, rolling all over the deck. As the Rolling Stones noted on a different matter, he “can turn off and on more times than a flashing neon sign.” Given the season, it should be a joyous time, but with the present erratic behavior at 1600 Pennsylvania, all good wishes are conditional.

Starting at /week.