Breaking News
Editorials

Raylee’s Law

Legislature Fails to Pass Amendment

2 min read

Lawmakers made some good decisions regarding the state House Education Committee's substitute for House Bill 5180. They reinstated a requirement that those providing home instruction to students must have a minimum of a high school diploma or equivalent. They removed a section that would have exempted homeschool, micro school and learning pod students who choose to attend a public school class from vaccine requirements.

But, bafflingly, they failed to pass an amendment that would have required the removal of children from homeschool environments during active child abuse investigations.

Del. Mike Pushkin, D-Kanawha, had tried to amend the bill by including language from Raylee's Law -- House Bill 4491, which would allow county boards of education to reject a request for homeschooling by a parent if there is a pending child abuse or neglect investigation against a parent, guardian, and or a person serving as a child's instructor. It would also prohibit homeschooling by a parent, guardian, or instructor who has been convicted of domestic violence, child abuse, or neglect.

The attempt to do what so many lawmakers claim they want to do -- protect kids -- failed in a 5-15 vote.

It begs the question: Is individual freedom paramount in the case of potential child abuse and neglect, but forgettable when we're discussing a host of other matters over which some lawmakers want control?

Then again, these are the same folks who decided the freedom to knowingly endanger the health of a child by smoking in a vehicle while that child is forced to ride along was also worth protecting.

Voting down the Raylee's Law-inspired amendment will purportedly allow the other elements of HB 5180 to move forward.

It is difficult to imagine anyone could have been so against the amendment as to raise objections that would have obstructed other worthwhile pieces of the bill, but here we are.

Surely some of those committee members who vocally supported the amendment will find a way to bring it back in another form. It is too late for Raylee. But, sadly, there are too many other children in West Virginia waiting to be saved.

Starting at /week.