Breaking News
Editorials

Randolph BOE’s Surprising Votes

3 min read

On Thursday night, the Randolph County Board of Education surprised many local residents by voting against taking the first steps in a Comprehensive School Realignment plan that aimed to close two county schools.

If approved, Superintendent of Schools Dr. Derek Lambert’s recommended plan would have allowed the county’s school system to move forward with the planning and completion of closure impact statements, and the scheduling of closure hearings for Pickens School and Midland Elementary.

Two votes were taken, one regarding the Pickens part of the realignment plan, and the other centering on the Midland part of the plan.

The Pickens vote deadlocked at 2-2, with one board member recusing himself because his wife works at the school. The Board then voted down the Midland Elementary section, by a 3-2 vote.

The plan would have closed Pickens School, with those students merging into existing George Ward Elementary and Tygarts Valley Middle/High School.

The plan also would have closed Midland Elementary, with those students merging into existing Beverly Elementary School.

The BOE’s votes on Thursday night were surprising because most onlookers assumed the Board would allow the Comprehensive School Realignment plan to begin, allow the closure hearings for the schools to take place, and then after all that, vote on whether to close the schools or not.

Instead, Board members decided to spare residents the turmoil of the closure hearings that the county experienced in 2025, when the BOE twice voted on whether to close the Harman School, eventually voting to close it, along with North Elementary School, in October 2025. Both schools shut their doors for the last time this May.

Also in October 2025, the BOE voted against closing Midland Elementary and Coalton Elementary.

The closing of the Pickens School was also originally to be voted on last year, but the hearing and vote were canceled by then-Superintendent Dr. Shawn Dilly, who said "new information related to funding" had arisen. That information was never shared with the public.

The West Virginia Board of Education originally placed Randolph County Schools in a State of Emergency for a six-month period in June 2025 because of its inability to balance the 2026 budget. The state BOE then voted to extend the State of Emergency status for another six months in January of this year.

In July, the state BOE voted unanimously during its monthly meeting on Wednesday morning to release Randolph County Schools from its State of Emergency status.

It is unclear where Thursday’s votes leave the county school system. The financial problems the system is facing are real, and something - either closing schools or reducing staff, or perhaps both - will have to be done in order to balance the budget. But for this moment, the school system’s future seems to be floating in limbo, which is surprising, if not necessarily reassuring.

Starting at /week.